Rankled Rankings

When I was applying to Ph.D. programs in 1996, I consulted the National Research Council’s rating of anthropology departments. The data were relatively fresh, the rankings were clearly numbered, and I had the confidence that they had been compiled by a neutral observer.

After a long wait, the new ratings have been released. Unlike the previous version, these rankings are unlikely to settle any debates. They rely on departmental data from 2005, they employ mind-boggling complex methodologies, and end up with wildly disparate conclusions.

As pointed out in Inside Higher Ed, by reporting confidence levels and not absolute rankings, the results end up conveying very little. The Communications Department at UT Austin could be the #1 program in the country or the 69th. Nonetheless, Boston University already trumpeted the performance of its departments on its website.

The problem is, BU reduced a very complex system to a single number. The NRC refused to endorse one system of ranking over another, so BU can be accused of selectively highlighting the most favorable outcomes. For instance, Geography, one of BU’s top-rated programs in terms of faculty research, sends only 35% of its graduates onto academic jobs and has one of the lowest percentages of female faculty in its field. As exhaustive as the NRC data are, without a clear understanding of what constitutes academic excellence, the rankings question will go unanswered.


6 Responses to “Rankled Rankings”

  1. Hallo Ich will mich bei einer Privaten Krankenkasse anmelden. Hier wurde mir klar wie gross die unterschiede bei den Beitraegen sind. Nicht selten zahlt eine Familie sehr viel mehr als bei anderen der Service ist schon sehr unterschiedlich. Die eine oder andere Firma hat ein super das keinen guten Leumund andere wiederum sind sehr kulant. Schlussendlich hab ich sehr viele Webpages im www und bei Google gefunden meine Frage, woher weiss ich welche die alles besten sind? Bei dieser Webseite habe ich sehr gute Infos aufgefunden die Frage ist ob das gut genug ist. http://haupt-beratung.com Wo bekommt man den besten Schutz? Webseiten wie sind echt super aber es wuerde mich sehr viel bringen wenn Ihr mir zusatzt Infos geben koenntet. Tausend Dank!

  2. Visitor recommendations… […]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[…]……

  3. This is exactly what I was hunting for. I wanted something small, w/ good sound and portable. This docking station delivers. The sound grade is great considering how puny it is. Of course to much of anything is bad, so if you decide to turn it all the way up, you may blow the speakers. I dont think it was made to perform the whole community. It suits all i pods, even the iphone, and the best is that is doubles as a charger.

  4. That was very informative post. I love your take on the topic.

  5. I believe that one of your ads caused my internet browser to resize, you may well want to set up that on your blacklist.

  6. Hiya, I’m really glad I have found this information. Nowadays bloggers publish only about gossips and net and this is actually irritating. A good website with exciting content, this is what I need. Thanks for keeping this web-site, I will be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Can’t find it.