ESPN, The World Wide Leader…

I sit here trying to write something scholarly about Rob King‘s visit to the B-U sports journalism seminar series and all I can think about it watching Steph Curry’s Saturday night performance against Oklahoma City AGAIN!!… I mean, i loved Oscar Robertson and still think he was one of the top ten all time players but c’mon Big O, you couldn’t stop this guy,  you didn’t have guys that could shoot from 35 at a 47% clip!… It’s a different game!…..be right back(gotta watch that again)…Curry had a better field goal percentage from 3 point land than he did from 2! (75% vs 58%)…That’s why we watch SportsCenter  religiously…

The Senior Vice President of News and SportsCenter rails against the critics who say they are not about highlights…Too much this (taking heads), not enough that (hockey)…If Curry keeps throwing up games like this, King won’t have to worry about people watching…

E-S-P-N’s coverage of Tom Brady the last year hasn’t made them very popular here in New England but let’s be honest, they do a lot of things right…”We were way out front on mobile publishing” said King “What you do, what you think, the way you wake up in the morning, what you want to consume, drives our business, not the other way around”…On the flip side, King recognizes some of their shortcomings, “Our mission is so big, that by definition, we’re constantly pushing up against the edges”…

So why didn’t Durant call a timeout?

That doesn’t excuse being wrong and inaccurate reporting…”Some of our biggest problems come from sources”,  King told the group…

And then there was being called out by a local sports talk radio show for allegedly telling their anchors NOT to report on Peyton Manning and his problems at the University of Tennessee…”What we said was we’re not just going to report this story until we can verify some of the material in it and those guys(WEEI) got a call from somebody in our group who has a relationship with them saying we just got told not to report on Peyton Manning…And nothing sets people’s teeth on edge here(New England) like the notion that we would treat Peyton Manning differently than we would treat Tom Brady”…Was that not reporting a story?…..I don’t think so…

And why did Durant foul Andre Iguodala?

It started with a lot of Austrailan Rules football back some thirty seven years ago, weaved its way through college basketball, NFL football and Major League Baseball and yes it IS the “Entertainment Sports and Programming Network” but face it, we all watch and cant wait to see what the Top 10 plays are…Hey, B-U made it twice!…Go Terriers!

I’d love to write more but i gotta go watch those highlights again….Cue the music! – do do do, do do do 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

You Talkin to Me?

You might not come face to face with  Travis Bickle in a professional locker room/clubhouse but overstep your bounds and a media relations person just might pull you aside...There are "rules of engagement", so to speak, some are written, some not, but all come with experience on the job....

Take, for example, this sign posted on  the New York Yankees spring training clubhouse door....Some say it was put there for the players to read as they try to reverse their second place finish of a year ago....It might be argued it was put there for media members as well....

 

yankees clubhouse sign

 

 

Let's try and figure out what they meant....."Motivated Professionals Only" - why are you there?....Is it to get information or is it to make a name for yourself?...Know the proper time or place...let's go to the videotape!

"By entering here, you agree to give 100% of what you have"...hello Larry Merchant!

"There are no excuses"...not even for angry athletes right Mike?

"Do not squander your time going through the motions"...can you say Jose Mourinho?

"Train hard and get results"...get those interviews that will get the athlete to remember you...you never know, someday they might have their own T-Vshow...

"At the end of the day, look in the mirror and ask yourself if you gave it your all"...were you willing to stand up for your convictions?... Tim McCarver was...

And finally, "If you don't have the level of commitment, don't waster your time or ours"...Torts and Brooksie ...

Who knows, maybe it was for the players but it sure looked appropriate to me...Sarah McMahon is the media relations person for the Providence Bruins and has, on more than one occasion, had to pull someone aside, "I've had to talk to a few people and it's uncomfortable, she said, but it only benefits them."

Michael Jurovaty of the New England Patriots agrees, "Be there to do your job, you're not fan boys/girls, be respectful of people working."

Remember, you're the (invited) guest here...Take advantage of the resources at your disposal, including the media relations people...But keep in mind, as Jurovaty so aptly articulated, "We can't control the questions but we can control the answers, we can control the message"...

It's all part of the game......

 

 

 

 

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly…

It may be the greatest western ever made but working in sports journalism can sometimes be just like the 1966 spaghetti western The Good, the Bad and the Ugly...There are highs, there are lows and there are things about it that are just plain awful....Sure you might get to a Super Bowl, a World Series, a Stanley Cup or even an Olympics but all those won't come without long, long hours and sacrifices along the way...

When we chose to talk beat reporting at the Boston University sports journalism seminar series recently,  we were lucky enough to have three reporters who have experienced all three facets of the business...

Doug Kyed of NESN.com just came back from covering his second Super Bowl...That might seem like a plum assignment and while it's the ultimate game each year, the team Doug covers on a regular basis, the New England Patriots, had lost two weeks earlier and the job just wasn't the same...Tim Britton, Boston Red Sox beat writer from the Providence Journal is getting ready to cover a season that could very well last nine months...And Adam Himmelsbachof the Boston Globe is in the throes of a Boston Celtics playoff push that might see him travel to exotic cities like Indianapolis, Toronto, Cleveland and Oakland ,perhaps, before his season ends....

Decide for yourself what part of all that is the good, the bad and the ugly but beat reporting is the staple of any media outlet...Fans can't get enough of their local team and the reporters that follow them are widely read...

Working during the game is a required skill now...One can't just sit back and watch the game, get locker room quotes and file...As Himmelsbach pointed out "Live tweeting is something you can tell a follower they might not have known.  Keep them engaged with you. This encourages readers who actually want to read your stories."... Kyed works long hours and sometimes is the last one out of the building, "I don't want to leave until they're(other reporters) leaving because I feel like I haven't done enough."...Britton tweets the entire (baseball) game and while his counterparts cover sports where there are definite time limits, he knows he always has time to recoup, "Baseball always gives you the bottom of the 9th"...Many a story has been re-written in those final three outs...

Length of season plays a part in both the reporters mental health and ease of establishing relationships...So too does roster size interestingly...The Celtics carry 15 players but not everyone takes off their sweats...So, you're talking to the same people every night..."It's really bad, says Himmelsbach, you're always focusing on only the people who actually play in the game."...Kyed finds a different set of circumstances at Patriots camp...Only a handful of players are available and then there's Bill Belichick...Britton and Himmelsbach admitted to watching their brethren try to elicit information.  "I like to hear creative ways journalists try to get stuff out of him", said Himmelsbach...

Learning the tools to work your way through the beat reporting minefield is certainly essential and important....But that first job, that first spot sets the tone for what kind of a reporter you eventually will be..."Everyone should cover high schools", said Himmelsbach, to which Kyed heartily agreed...Britton added, "It helps you develop relationships"...Imagine, as Himmelsbach drew from his memory bank, "You have to find players who cost his team the game and he's crying!  You have to talk to him by yourself"...We can't teach that particular skill at the seminar series...

It's not always fancy hotels and five star restaurants on the road or popcorn eating hours in the Fenway/Gillette/TD Garden press box...It's a grind...When people would ask me what it was like to work in Boston television sports I would remember red eye flights crossing the country in a seven game Celtics - Lakers series or working thirty straight days at the Atlanta Olympics from seven in the morning until one at night..."It sucked while it was happening but I wouldn't have missed it for the world" I would tell them...Kyed said it succinctly, "I'm only friends with my friends for six months of the year"...

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly....

 

It’s Okay to Be Wrong…

It's okay to be wrong...

It's okay t0 post something and correct it later...

You can always take it down (and that way it's like it never existed)...

Is this really the state of sports journalism in 2016?...It sure seems that way...I thought we had dealt with the issue of being accurate a long time ago but apparently not...And just as apparently we've come to accept misinformation as common practice...As long as we get those page views....Well, count me out!...

It's never going to be okay to be wrong even if the ability to "edit" or "delete" exists...Whether it's Twitter, thebiglead or even Facebook, get it right!...ESPN senior writer Jerry Crasnick was interviewed in the Setonian just recently and he put it this way, "“I think it’s (Twitter) produced a lot more errors and inaccurate reporting than we used to see,” Crasnick said. “And there are typically no consequences when someone reports something that’s flat-out wrong.  “But I do try to constantly remind myself that there’s a difference between real reporting and noise,” he adds. “I hope that readers can discern the difference, but I’m not sure if that’s the case anymore.‬”

Jen McCaffrey and Jason Mastrodonato visited the Boston University sports journalism seminar series recently and while the discussion was intended to focus on where we stand in the year 2016,  it quickly turned to an analysis of a disturbing trend..."It's all about web traffic, said McCaffrey,  and what you can do to grow web traffic and everything you do  is based off how well received is this gonna be by your internet audience.  You're still putting the news out everyday but my editor would very much want you to write that story about (David) Ortiz's haircut because fans will click on that and say where's the picture..."

We spent some time talking about a just published piece on thebiglead dealing with layoffs at CBS Sports.com and their movement toward the very same issue...Writes one unnamed source "Years ago we never heard of the word "pageviews".  Then we started getting monthly reports and your judged on pageviews more than anything else.  It's more important to be successful on Facebook than it is to break news..."

Is that really the case or cant we just do both?...Writing on tumblr.com, Craig Calcaterra took exception with the article saying,  "They’ve taken the position that, if customers are no longer interested in buying a product, it’s not worth acknowledging their changing tastes and not worth trying to adapt their business approach to provide it. Rather, they seem to think, the solution is to excoriate the competitor who came in and supplied it..." Like it or not, change is inevitable... The reality is some accept it more slowly than others...

Mastrodonato seems to disagree however,  stating, "I tend to think that it's not as bleak as it looks right now. We haven't figured it out yet (but we will)"...Covering the Boston Red Sox in his mid-twenties, Mastrodonato is doing something right...He brings a refreshing perspective to the job, one he was willing to share with the class..."Figure out who you are as a person so you can figure out who you are as a journalist.  Ask yourself questions all on the way.  Make sure you're evolving to figure out who you are so you can figure out who you want to be as a journalist."

And it says here that is exactly the point...Sports journalism and sports journalists should be doing the very same, asking themselves questions and evolving (to fit their audience)...

But it's never okay to be wrong and it's never okay to fall back on "I can always change it later"...

 

 

 

Can’t We All Just Get Along?

The truth is, you just never know what you're going to get when you interview an athlete...Whether it be in the locker room or from the podium, you always need to be on your toes...With all due respect to Dionne Warwick, making eye contact is never dull....

As a journalist, the way you get along  with the athletes you cover is the measure of your success... You never know what kind and just how much access you'll have when you cover a team and if you can't manage the relationship, you'll get beat on stories and never have their trust...

Sean Mcadam of ComcastSportsnet New England joined us at the Boston University sports journalism seminar series along with Boston Celtics players R.J. Hunter and Jordan Mickey as well as Providence Bruins forward Austin Czarnik and it was clear that they have spent time defining their brand(s)...

Between the three of them, Mickey, Czarnik and Hunter have only two and a half seasons of pro experience...They're still learning but saying the right things as they learn to deal with the New England Media....They've been through league media training and in Mickey's case, extensive training at L-S-U, a high profile collegiate program..."Put the team before yourself, says Mickey, never mention the "I".  Always praise your school, your coaches, whatever organization you're under at that time."...Austin is in his second year with the Baby B's and while the team doesn't have the tradition post game locker room access he's up front about agreeing with Mickey..."You throw out your linemates names, like "they're a huge part of my success, dishing it out" you're not just taking the credit."

But let's be clear, much of this can lead to pretty boring stuff, making your job, of entertaining as well as informing your audience even harder...Unless of, course your coach happens to be someone like John Tortarella....Having a media savvy person on the team you cover can be a godsend...Even in a negative way...Just ask Larry Brooks of the New York Post...

McAdam understands that all too well, having dealt with any number of players and coaches while covering the Boston Red Sox...Accepted almost universally as the hardest athletes to deal with, McAdam says it's complicated..."A lot of it depends on how the team is doing.  My experience is that , not surprisingly, the better the team is performing, the happier the athletes usually are and more likely to open up a bit."...And as a whole the landscape has changed, says McAdam, "Players are less accessible, everything is a little more managed now.  There's less opportunity to talk to athletes on a one on one basis."

And that doesn't even take into account player's own websites, sites like The Players' Tribune...We'll deal with that as the semester goes along...

It's a unique experience going into any locker room for the first time...Being star struck is very common but besides learning the proper etiquette young reporters may literally come face to face with uncomfortable experiences...Hunter said, "You might walk in and see like 4 or 5 naked people so you kind of have to brace for that but other than that it's (the Celtics locker room) pretty relaxing...Indeed...

Hunter gave us one of 2015's memorable media moments...Not only did his three pointer beat Baylor last year in the first round of the N-C-A-A tournament but it set up a dramatic podium post game speech by his coach and father Ron Hunter...  If you were lucky enough to be covering that game, he pretty much did your job for you...And that not often the case...

Go slowly, tread lightly, learn the rules and remember, they are people too, talented athletically yes, but they were once rookies too...

 

It’s Up to You Now…

It's up to you now...what kind of journalist will you be?  Undoubtedly, at first, the fact that you're working in the "biz" will be the hook...But where does it go from there?  If you've been a follower of this blog or a student at the seminar series, I hoped you've picked up enough along the way to have a pretty good clue...The guests and events of this just past week certainly drove home some salient points in 2015...

"Accountability of the bloggers, the tweeters, of high school kids", warned Rob Bradford of WEEI.com.  "So many of these other people (other than he and his fellow working reporters, i presume) want to be this but they don't have the experience, they don't know what they're doing, and more importantly, they don't have the accountability.  If someone from the (Boston)Globe or (Boston)Herald is as wrong as some of these people, they're fired!  they're fired! And it's a trend that's not going to stop.  You can do whatever you want!"

Kirk Minihane , also of WEEI joined Bradford in our final session and if there was anyone who seems to be doing anything he wants, it's Minihane.... His on air dust-ups with Joe Haggerty and Gary Tanguay might have been a bit contrived but the talk show host seems to be almost lamenting the lack of personality in the industry at the same time.  "There's nobody young that's made an impact here (Boston) in a long time.  There's nobody in their 20's, their 30's that's kicking ass on the radio, on t-v, in print, that next generation kind of thing.  It's open, open for someone who's not afraid to take chances."  I'm not sure we can chalk these incidents up to "chances" but it's still an interesting proposition.  Do we really need to revisit the Erin Andrews rant?  Boston sports talk radio is littered with vanilla, middle of the road hosts who couldn't get listeners to listen. Local television is worse, the format is king in that medium, not the players.  So maybe Minihane has something there.

So how do you put yourself out there and still be help accountable? One needed only to have an eye on Las Vegas this past week and you just might have found  your answer...

Michelle Beadle and Rachel Nichols stood up for their own beliefs (being accountable to themselves) in spotlighting Floyd Mayweather's history of domestic violence leading up to the fight with Manny Pacquiao and look what happened.  Showtime denied the pair credentials for the fight.  But who was the loser here?  I'm thinking it was the boxing types and not the reporters.  At some point you have to decide what's the real issue here.

It's up to you now...

Access and accountability, two subjects virtually every seminar has touched on over the past our months...It's up to you now to put into play what we've tried to pass along...

Can’t We All Just Get Along?

"You don't really need us"...Us, according to Kevin Gregg of the Boston Red Sox,  happens to be the media relations people associated with any sports team...It says here nothing could be further from the truth...But while twitter and other social media sites have opened access to athletes, the P.R. types are still your best source of contact with the players...

For students who've never been in that locker room setting Gregg and Eric Tosi of the Boston Bruins had valuable advice at the just recent Boston University Sports Journalism Seminar...."If you've been given the opportunity to cover a team, you have a lot of talent, said Tosi, also the Executive Producer of the Bruins television show "Behind the B"... That's pretty high praise at any point in your career...

Media Relations types were, for a very long time, the sole source of team and player information...What these very same teams found out was that they could "break" the news themselves without first dishing it to the local media outlets...It started with faxes but as much as that spread the news, the teams didn't have direct access to the fans....Enter the website, enter Twitter...And make no mistake, it had an affect on the local stations (radio and t-v) who found themselves being scooped..."What you're seeing now is that more teams are controlling their own news and they are becoming their own news outlet", said Tosi...Maybe that opening line should be reversed, at least as far as disseminating information goes, "We don't really need YOU!".....

But of course they do...Teams still need to get the story out ...They rely on the people who cover the team to keep them in the public's attention....

At some point in every sports journalist's career there comes the point where you're want to cover a game, a game perhaps outside our regular beat...And you'll need the access to do it... Gaining that access means calling the "keepers of the gate"...As you might imagine, Gregg gets many calls to cover the Olde Town team and it's not always possible for him to say yes, especially for people he's never met, "I would do some research on my own to see what they have written, check any references that are available.  I would be protective of the clubhouse (however).  I may arrange for something away from the clubhouse, you want to avoid people being in there who are unfamiliar so the players are uncomfortable.  And, oh yes, no pictures with the players!"...

Tosi and Gregg can be your best friends, your worst nightmares..."Be approachable, if you build a relationship based on trust with these guys, that's the main way to succeed", advised Gregg...Tosi added, "You don't want it ever to be adversarial.  There are going to be times when we tell you no.  But that's just the reality of it"...

We spent a lot of time this semester introducing you to issues and situations you've perhaps never experienced, never thought of...hopefully your "media relation-ship" is a good one....

Just Measure It In Inches, Column Inches, That Is…

Face it, no one likes to be criticized...especially the people on TV, especially the people on ESPN!...As Ken Fang of Fang's Bites said at the just recent Boston University sports journalism seminar,  "We got ratings, we don't care (what they say?)"..."We", of course, is ESPN and for the most part, while they are the acknowledged leader in sports (news) television, even they had to blanch at the negative publicity they got after Britt Mchenry's much publicized outburst ....

While the initial reaction to the McHenry video was all negative, suddenly we're hearing a different viewpoint...considering the New York Post article of April 17th...And then there was this from Joe Concha on Mediaite...Legendary sportscaster Howard Cosell was famous for his line "Say what you want about me, just spell my name right"...Maybe it's that simple...

Robert Lipsyte has been writing media criticism for a long time....A distinguished author, he just wrapped up his eighteen month tenure as the Ombudsman or ESPN recently...Joining Fang at the seminar, Lipsyte embraced the "watchdog" role and wondered what was expected of him, "Are we here to be investigative reporters, are we here to embrace and pleasures of the game?...If you're in a small market or any kind of market where the local team or local college team is important, you know how you have to cover it."  Good advice for young journalists about to head out...

Unquestionably, these columns are scrutinized as much by the people they are about than by the readers/viewers but, in this writers opinion, they have their place...It remains to be seen who the next watchdog will be at ESPN but both Lipsyte and Fang think there's a need, "Someone has to hold them accountable.  I think they'll admit the need to be challenged, said Fang.   Not just ESPN but the other networks and the print organizations too."

But remember, as Lipsyte agreed, It's the Entertainment and Sports Programming Network.  "There was no journalism DNA built into  their system."  And as I said in the seminar, you can always change the channel...

The Digital Natives are Restless…

The best part about teaching, I've come to find out, is learning new things myself...And I have my students to thank for that...I never knew what a "digital native" was until last week...Don't get me started on "foodporn!"...Who coined that one?...My computer doesn't even recognize it as a word!...But luckily I can still teach a few things every now and then that these very same students will be able to use as they enter the workforce as first time sports journalists....  (When that's not the case, you'll find me elsewhere)...

It's spring and another class is getting ready to graduate...And they're scared...Four years has gone by way too quickly and the reality is here...I need a job...Well, you're in luck...Because sports jobs are there for the taking and anyone who tells you otherwise simply doesn't understand the landscape...Maybe not in Boston and New York and Los Angeles but as we've hammered away, Jackson, MS and Tyler, TX are the price you have to be willing to pay...

News Director Mike Redding of WCSH TV in Portland, Maine put it this way, "Sports will always have a rabid fan base, always.  The sports industry will always exist so there will be jobs for you.  You're in a really good field that will always exist."...  What more do you want to hear?...ESPN isn't coming to Elkhart, Indiana to cover sports...But WSVJ TV is and that won't ever change...You might be a "one man/woman band" but those jobs will always exist...

And if that doesn't convince you, listen to Boston Herald Editor Sean Leahy wax poetic about your readiness..."Most editors will glance at it (video) and not really absorb it but they'll say he/she does video.  So yeah, I want to see that.  I want to see multimedia skills.  I want to see(hear) you're good on the radio,  good on TV.  We need people who can do more things and do them well."  Talented people will always find a place...

Which bring us to the issue of appearance...Television is notorious for hiring only good looking, spray tanned, coiffed, constantly smiling Barbies and Kens...Maybe, not so much anymore however, says Redding.  "I want people to be critical thinkers.  I don't need beauty queens or movie stars.  You don't want people to get lost in what you look like because they're not listening to what you are telling them.   We're supposed to look like regular humans and comb our hair and know how to put on TV makeup sure.  Sports is the the place that best accomplishes that.  Sports reporters in every television station are the best (on) camera people we have.  News people are boring and stale and formulaic.  And you just want to stab them in the eyeball!"

Reading that ought to get you "pumped and jacked"... Bit do yourselves a favor, don't go calling a pass play on second and goal from the one!,,,You can do this, you're ready!

 

Tell it Like it Is….

Very late in the just recent Men's NCAA semi-final basketball game between Kentucky and Wisconsin, play by play announcer Jim Nance uttered what struck me as not only a highly debatable phrase but one that showed a lack of historical perspective....As the Badgers were about to dispatch the Wildcats and ruin the perfect season, Nance said (something like),  "...this has been the greatest(one of) semi-final game in NCAA history"...Now granted Kentucky was unbeaten and either way the result would have been stunning but in my mind, it's just this kind of hyperbole that sets play by play announcers up to fail...I'm not about to formulate a list of the greatest Final Four games of all time but let's be realistic, this one wouldn't make the top ten....It was an okay game but there just might have been more suspense in the earlier game, Duke and Michigan State with $1 million dollars on the line for one college hoop fan...Coincidentally, this is the 50 year anniversary of the epic battle between Michigan's Cazzie Russell and Princeton's Bill Bradley, a game that saw the a pair of future teammates go head to head, Russell getting 28, Bradley 29 as the Wolverines prevailed....Easily one of the standards under Nance's thinking...

The play by play announcer has one job, to describe the action...So when Bob Socci and Jon Meterparel visited the Boston University sports journalism seminar series recently, it came as no surprise that they had very definite ideas as to their responsibility on air..."You just wanna get it right, said Socci, every game is the biggest game you're gonna call"...Despite the surge in sales of large screen TVs, sports fans still watch on the "small screen", literally...And they rely on the play by play person to describe what's going on...Everyone has their favorites, everyone has their least favorites...Website like Awful Announcing and Deadspin have made a living from chronicling miscues...The same goes for lists of Top Ten Best Calls...Take your pick...

My pet peeve has always been announcers who describe everything that's going on, especially on television...Is it any wonder fans sometimes turn off the sound and listen to the radio call?...Meterparel has done both TV and radio and he says there's a not so subtle difference, especially when it comes to working a game with a partner..."Incorporating your analyst to make it more of a talk show around the game (is important) from a radio perspective.  TV is a polar opposite.  It's kind of like connect the dots but you have to be very descriptive in radio."

Let's face it, viewers feel like they know just as much about the players and the game as the people they tune into listen to...The viewers/listeners  want it down the middle though ...You want to entertain me along the way, throw in a well researched anecdote? Fine...But don't try to impress me(us) with every little number(stat) you've found...Some of the greatest calls in history haven't lasted more than five words! "Down Goes Frazier!", "Havlicek Stole the Ball!", "The Giants Win the Pennant!"...Identify with your audience, understand their passion...You might be just lucky enough to say "I Don't Believe What I Just Saw!"...