The Sword and Four Dragons drag Democracy

Written by Sihun Kim
Graphic Designed by Sihun Kim

The viewpoints expressed in this article are those of the author, and do not in any way reflect the beliefs and viewpoints of the CELOP Sun, CELOP, or Boston University

 

5 flags

 

Political Issues in Capitalism in Countries in East Asia

 

The productivity of Japan, a  country involved in  World War II, was paralyzed. The United States, which occupied Japan, made a plan for the defeated nation to behave as if it was an Alps country of Asia; a peaceful agrarian country like Switzerland. In addition, they prepared a partition plan for Japan with their Allies; the United Kingdom, the Republic of China, and the Soviet Union. However, a war in Korea, (a neighboring country of Japan), which entailed the conflict of the capitalism of the South and the communism of the North made them change their minds about the necessity of making Japan into a strong country and  a front line defender of the United States due to the fear of communism. The Japanese industry had been revived by special procurements from the war in Korea. Those responsible for war crimes returned to the political world. Under a strong one-party rule and supporting western countries, the Japanese economy recovered beyond the war period. They held the Olympic games in Tokyo, 1964. They became the model for Asian values. As a result, the four countries which had been influenced by Japan, such as S.Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore, turned to dictatorship governments which sought economic development . The page below introduces Japan, also called the Chrysanthemum and the Sword, as well as Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Singapore, known as the Asian four dragons. They succeeded in economic growth following Japan.

 

Japan2

Japan

After World War II, Japan, one of countries of the Axis of power, had been divided between the conservatives and the progressives in their political ideologies. In spite of the disbanding of the Nazis,  the Japanese rightists were able to survive. The damage suffered by western allies was from Germany but not from Japan. Therefore the Japanese politicians weren’t punished by the Western countries despite the damage they caused. Nevertheless the Japanese conservatives could not ignore the progressives even though they still had political power. However, after the leader of the progressives was assassinated by a young boy of the conservatives in 1960, Japanese politics began to turn to to the right. After the conservative party had support, civic movements shackled and dissolved. This movement turned out to be an underground-organization. During the dictatorship of the conservatives for 50 years, the movement receded into the dim past by Japanese citizens who had experienced high economic development. During this high-growth period, the government got huge support from Japanese citizens. On the other hand, the government distorted several facts, such as  the education of history, territorial issues, and post-war compensation issues. This caused friction between Japan and other surrounding countries. At the time of the 90’s during the economic crisis which was called the lost decade, the Progressive Party took over for a short period. However despite that short period, the Liberal Democratic Party was the first party of Japan. Unlike the opposition party, claiming the need to apologize to neighboring countries, the basic position of the Liberal Democratic Party was a consistently contradictory description. In the 21st century politicians, especially those who are right-wing and including the government party, participate in memorial events at Yasukuni Shrine. This facility is a memorial for war criminals of World War II. In addition, the government supported xenophobic organizations by deleting Japanese criminal acts that occurred during  the war from textbooks, thereby abolishing the Constitution Article 9 which prohibits the act of aggression to other countries. From this perspective the Japanese government stepped on militarism.

 

 

korea2

Republic of Korea (South Korea)

South Korea, gaining independence at the end of the World War II, had experienced the biggest political storms in East Asia. In S.Korea, a capitalist government had been destroyed in the war-torn by the invasion of N.Korea. As a result, there could not exist any political ideology except for right-wing conservatism in South. There were three military dictators under the guise of stability in the country. It had been a dark period because plenty of people who disagreed with the government policy had been accused of being  spies of N.Korea, so they received the death penalty or served sentences in prison, and the military attacked citizens. However, the first transfer of power from the conservatives to the progressives was done peacefully because of the economic crisis in 1998. S.Korea overcame the economic crisis under the new leaders control, but people wanted a strong leader who could boost the economy instead of a peaceful democratic leader.  As a result, a new conservative president ended a decade of liberal rule in 2008. The conservative party however, tried to made public facilities such as airports or public transportation systems their own possessions. This wasteful spending for civil work led to a draining of the nation’s budget. In 2012, the presidential election was took place. 51% of the votes could barely keep the conservative party in the regime, but not much later it emerged that national secret agents and the military had been involved in the election to change the results. The new government had a Seoul city hall official pegged as a N.Korean spy to resolve the crisis in 2013. However he was found innocent because of a document, which was submitted by the prosecution and identified as a fake document. In addition, a ferry accident in 2014 aroused suspicion that a government had been denied an emergency rescue to divert public attention.

 

 

taiwan2

Republic of China (Taiwan)

After World War II, the current government party of Taiwan which retreated from mainland  China to the Taiwanese islands because the  communist party took over . Taiwan is largely divided into a native-Taiwanese group, born on the island and an immigrant group, who came from mainland  China. Mostly, there are plenty of  immigrants in the government party and plenty of rich people in this group. After the Chinese civil war between the communists and the capitalists, the Chinese capitalist emigrated to the island. The native-Taiwanese had been discriminated  against as an immigrant group. At that time, the natives used to say unflattering things about the immigrants from the mainland because it was felt that the immigrants had exploited the natives more than the colonial exploitation policy of Japan. A native Taiwanese resistance in February 28, 1947, also known as  the 228 Incident gave much anguish to the Taiwanese because about 20,000 citizens were sacrificed by the military. Martial law had been declared since 1949 and lasted for 40 years. The opposition party had been banned by the law until the 1990’s. The National Assembly had elected a president until 1990. At that time the voting count of the government party was over 95% was quite similar to S. Korea in the military dictatorship  period of the 1970’s and also  the current situation in N. Korea. From 1996 to the present time, because the presidential election system had been changed into a direct election, the government party had taken 50% of the votes.  It was a result unlike previous elections, and in the election of 2000, the government party was defeated. It had became the first transfer of power from the government party to the opposition party. In 2008, the government party reclaimed its regime with a candidate who had come from Hong Kong, and his cabinet had operated the pro-Chinese line. However, it sparked the strong citizen opposition, and the party defeated a local election in major Taiwanese cities such as Taipei, Taichung, Kaohsiung, Taoyuan, and Tainan in 2014.

 

 

HongKong2

Hong Kong

Until 1997, Hong Kong had been a colony area of the United Kingdom. After 1997, when Hong Kong returned to China, Hong Kong was pledged broad autonomy when it returned to China in 1997 under a “one country, two systems” formula. Therefore, even though Hong Kong was just a small administrative area, they had high autonomy such as a constitution, an administration, and a supreme court. However, as time passed, the influence of the Chinese government  increased. First of all, even though a minister of Hong Kong had been elected by an election, the candidates could only be selected in the National People’s Congress of China that had been claimed by Hong Kong’s citizens. The citizens had  demanded a direct minister election, which had not been approved by the mainland government. Finally, the people began a civic movement known as the Umbrella Revolution against the Chinese government and to keep their democracy. The revolution began September 26, 2014, and it continued for 3 months. All Hong Kong universities had joined in this movement, and spread to not only college students and intellectuals but also to regular citizens and high school students. The revolution had been operated as peaceful and it was introduced to the foreign media as the Umbrella Revolution because participants had used an umbrella to cover their bodies from tear gas, which was fired by the police. As time went  by, the protesters lost their power, and the movement  finished in December 15. Even though the citizens could not get democracy, its ideals have spread in Hong Kong and the government is presently an eyesore in politics. Furthermore, the government party of Taiwan which a co-operative party for the Chinese government had been defeated in a local election in Taiwan. The Chinese government, which had been seeking One China, took a hard-hit.

 

 

Sinagapore2

Singapore

Singapore, one of the colonies of the United Kingdom, is a unique country which is the most successful economically but a failure in democracy. To reference Singaporean politics, it needs just one person. There is a strong man in Singapore who  became an attorney in London and became a famous person while he had been attending a labor activity. In 1959, he became a leader of the Singaporean self-government, and he sought to join the Federation of Malaysia, in the hope of helping it survive. However, in August of 1965, Singapore was kicked out from the Federation because the Malaysian government viewed Singapore, where the most population is Chinese, as a threat. Singapore, gained independence by force and decided pursue economic development with a strong rule. As a result, Singapore became an economic leader in East Asia. In addition, Singapore is ranked successfully as one of the places with the lowest crime rates and the lowest corruption rates as compared with other counties.  This is mentioned on this page because of the strong social rule such as large fines, flogging, and beyonds common ideas. The Prime Minister of Singapore ruled Singapore for 30 years, and has been accused of being monopolizing the country’s wealth. His son  successfully gained his father’s seat as the Prime Minister as well as riches. Due to these actions, Singapore was sometimes referred to as the rich North Korea. Due to his controlling nature, the country has always monitored the Internet and the media. As a result, they recorded the lowest level of speech freedom rate in the world. Korean dictators have violently put down those who oppose the regime; however, in Singapore, most  companies are in  his possession, so he already has control. He controls the masses through punishment by using the judicial system of law from the government side and his economic status. He died yesterday, and has been attracting attention and his death may result in changes to the democracy of Singapore.

One thought on “The Sword and Four Dragons drag Democracy

  1. Thank you, Sihun, for your description of these countries. It was really informative and interesting.
    Regards,
    Ellen Yaniv

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *