Losing My Religion?

Although I don’t have the same beliefs I did as I a child growing up and I consider myself to be more secular and pluralist than what I was taught, I cannot say that I have lost any faith in god or religion. On the contrary, I believe that my spiritual practices have deepened and that I have become much more “religious” or “spiritual” as I’ve gotten older because I am willing to go into other sacred spaces and see the ways in which others practice their beliefs.

 

Christian, Jew, Muslim, shaman, Zoroastrian, stone, ground, mountain, river, each has a secret way of being with the mystery, unique and not to be judged. -Rumi

 

From what I have come to understand, reaching god is like climbing a mountain. The goal is to get to the top, but there isn’t just one way or direction to get to it, there are many and what Kind of explorer would limit themselves to only one way to climb the mountain or to climb only one mountain when there are many ways to climb one mountain and many mountains to climb.

Although I do not practice in the same manner I did as a kid, I see no difference in what I do now with what I did then as I am still attempting to experience god. Whether I go to a temple, synagogue, mosque, church, tree, lake, river, or mountain; I believe that I am in good hands as I am surrounded by god.

my friend.

I think spirituality has become very different for me over my time at Boston University. I don't think that I have many spiritual practices because spirituality has become so casual to me. Since coming to college I have stood in the belief that Jesus is my best friend and that he walks with me everywhere I go. I can't think about what is spiritual or not because it seems it could apply to any and everything that I do. A few years ago if you would have asked me this question, I would have said going to church would be a spiritual practice, but I don't think that is true for me anymore. Being in the church can at times be spiritual, but I don't think my spirituality is confined to the walls of the church. Music is probably the only consistent spiritual practice that I have had in my life. What I see as spiritual has changed greatly, I think Howard Thurman was correct in saying that you can connect the spiritual to most things in life. I think I'm most grateful for this change because I began to understand and appreciate what other people see as spiritual. The beauty of the spiritual is its ability to change.

Listening for the Unexpected

As the son of a United Methodist pastor, the grandson of a United Methodist theologian, the grand-nephew of a widely-known United Methodist preacher, the grand-nephew of a United Methodist theology teacher, and even the great-grandson of an Irish immigrant Methodist clergy, the term Methodist carries a great deal of meaning in my life. Inundated with a Methodist-centric perspective from birth, my first eighteen years  focused almost solely on the United Methodist tradition and the practices of the denomination.

It was not until my freshman year at BU that I challenged myself to venture outside of the Methodist realm. I attended Roman-Catholic services, worked with individuals at Hillel, volunteered with a Protestant student group, and even dated a Mormon for a brief time. I quickly began to understand that some of my expectations of different religions were accurate and others were not.

Yet, what became most apparent throughout my experiences was the unexpected nature of religion, and more pointedly, faith. Though I did seek out certain experiences, other experiences simply happened upon me. My faith formation became an interesting combination of thoughtful action and improbable chance.

Throughout my time at BU I've found that my experience of other religions never fails to cease. I continue to meet fellow students from different faith backgrounds and denominations who challenge my perceived notions of the world and of who God is. In doing so, my spiritual practices have taken many different forms throughout my time in Boston.

However, prayer and music have always dominated my spiritual practices. Whether by singing or playing piano on Sunday's, music continues to be an unmistakeable tether to my belief in God. Quiet and shared prayer also tends to be a spiritual practice I value, yet I seem to pray much more when in times of strife and conflict.

The act of listening to the experiences and beliefs of others is a spiritual practice that I find most central to my college life at BU. Though I am seeped in familial United Methodism, choosing to open my ears to a chorus of new voices from different walks of social and ethnic spheres helped to strengthen my faith the most. These voices range from the intellectual members of the book study on Sunday mornings to the homeless man that sits outside of the CFA. They range from my Muslim Marsh Associate to my fellow Methodist Marsh Associate. They range from the pulpit of Dean Hill to the pulpit of my father. Sometimes these voices are unexpected. And in those unexpected moments is where I see God most.

 

Where I Want to Be

Spirituality is a strange and powerful thing. As someone who has grown up in a Catholic home and who has been raised with that faith, I can attest to the idea of “taking religion for granted”. From a young age, I understood the morals and themes of my belief as well as the obligation to attend particular services; however, to some extent, I was blind to see the impact religion has on one’s self. The moment that I stopped blindly walking through the motions of religion and began to hear what was happening around me, was the second that I saw how much larger spirituality is. I have found it to be so much more than those common routines. Religion expands the way you can see the world around you. As these horizons expand, new limits and be pushed and a person can discover more about their brothers and sisters around the world, as well as uncovering more about themselves.

However, the challenge with this idea that I face, is how do I push myself further?

I think that one clear option taught as a student is to simply pay more attention. It sounds naggy and simply but honestly, too often I find myself distracted and focused on what I will be doing next when I should be focused on a moment of prayer. These quick, self-centered bursts take my attention away from the lessons and teachings of the Lord. I believe that if I can channel myself more into the present tense during times of prayer, I will go so much further into what religion has to offer.

I believe that another viable (and probably more effective) option is to learn from everyone else! I think it is easy to fall into the trap of seeing one faith as my/your faith, and then labeling all the other religions as just that… other. This is something that I have come to actively avoid. I genuinely think that this is like looking at religion with blinders on as you only see one small bit of it. Spirituality in all forms is something that is so innately human that to ignore all but one leaf of it may very well result in seeing the world in a small and less empowering way. When a person can stretch past what they know in religion and begin to listen to and learn from the beliefs of others, then they will go so much further in seeing the world. “They are the ones who decided at some point that spirituality was a quest worth pursuing actively, a pursuit requiring time and energy” (Robert Wuthnow). This is a quest that I hope to continue if not truly start as my junior year begins.

Growing up A Church Kid

 

I was born and raised in Birmingham, AL and was baptized in the Episcopal church. My mom grew up Baptist, and my dad grew up Presbyterian. When my mom was in her 20s she discovered the Episcopal faith, and has been an Episcopalian ever since. When my dad married my mom, he converted from Presbyterian to Episcopalian.  I grew up in the Episcopal church, and I can remember from an early age going to Sunday school and singing songs and learning the Lord's Prayer . As I grew up I got more involved. I was in children's choir, acolyted, and was Crucifer on a few occasions. My parents were heavily involved in the diocese of Alabama, particularly Cursillo and Ultreya, and I would go along when I was as young as 2 years old.  I am still Episcopalian, and my faith has actually deepened over the years.

My spiritual practices have become vital for me at Boston University for two major  reasons. For one, my spiritual practices have provided me with a very solid foundation that I feel has given me something to stand on and has helped guide me through college these past two years and has helped lead me in the right direction in terms of decision making and choosing to do the right thing. Another way that my faith has become vital for me at Boston University is that it has given me a church family in a way because thanks to Marsh Chapel I have been able to make connections and friendships that I would not have otherwise experienced.

Lastly, my practices are both the same and different because there are components that are the same as I grew up with, but there are also a couple of differences. I am Episcopalian and I always have been and always will be. However, the difference is that my faith is actually stronger now than it was growing up because I feel more guided now than I did growing up throughout elementary, junior, and high school. Finally, there is a difference because I have connections and experiences that I did not have when I was younger.

A Mishmash Of Things

Growing up in my largely white small town in the largely white state of Minnesota, going to temple meant, at its most fundamental, seeing people who looked like me. I remember my time at temple as always joyful, chants perpetually buzzing in the air like the very pulse of the sanctum, little kids in bright salwars running around and occasionally sneaking bits of fruit and rice offerings when the priests weren’t looking.

As a kid, I never distinguished between religion and culture. I don’t know if the unwitting conflation made things more simple, or more complicated. Later I would explore this, the ways of Hindu nationalism and the deep seated roots tangled from the Partition; the meanings of national identity and God, and hatred and love. But then, as a kid, I didn’t know a whole lot about any of this. I didn’t know any Indian dialect and didn't know much about my "homeland" at all because we only went to India once a year or once every few years, as my parents worked full time. But of all the jumbled up pieces within me that made me diaspora and Indian and American, the one I understood the most was worship. Also, importantly, I felt that it understood me back. I convinced my parents to drive me out 45 minutes to the temple every Sunday morning for Sunday School and spent afternoons afterward at the temple, prayed every night with my family around our small shrine, and celebrated major holidays like Diwali with our family friends lighting diya candles and eating sweets. We did special pujas on birthdays, first days of school, etc in which we also lit incense and left it burning all night. When my grandfather was losing his sight and his motor skills due to a stroke, I taught myself the sacred Sanskrit script so I could carefully guide his hands, wrapping mine over his to trace the characters on pieces of paper. In Hinduism, it is said that God manifests a light within each of us. These moments were all precious to me because I felt the closest to that self light. I didn't ever take them for granted. I was always seeking them out, and I never thought I would feel doubt. 

There’s a line in Midnight Children by Salman Rushdie that’s resonated with me for a long time. It’s about the main character’s grandfather, Aadam Aziz, who’s Kashmiri in a time when the last vestiges of British rule are most prevalent there. He’s just come back from studying medicine in Europe and is constantly struggling with his clashing identities. He unrolls his prayer mat and prostrates himself, only to clunk himself in the head and give himself a bloody nose. The line goes: “And my grandfather… was knocked forever into that middle place, unable to worship a God in whose existence he could not wholly disbelieve. Permanent alteration: a hole.” As I grew up, I struggled with the cultural-generational gap between my first generation immigrant parents and my second generation self. As I grew away from traditional culture, I also grew away from traditional religion. I began to describe myself as agnostic. Reconnecting with Hindu worship would mean I had to face the turbulent and often traumatic experiences I had relating to the manifestation of cultural values within my personal narrative. An alteration that I believed permanent: my middle place. 

Attending BU allowed me the time I needed to recollect myself and finally make that distinction between traditional culture and my diaspora culture, and the way religion fit into all of that, and the way that I fit too. Worship requires vulnerability. Devotion requires trust. I found both of these characteristics through prayer. I sought this out because I believed it was an essential part of the sense of self I was carefully reconstructing. I finally began to understand that my relationship with God was just that: mine. It did not have to be connected to the problematic cultural values that my parents grew up learning and it did not have to be connected to toxic Hindu nationalism that I witnessed in the larger Indian American community as a uniting and powerful force. Instead it was about love and trust, finding strength, reflecting, and seeking out compassion and kindness, to name a few attributes. These characteristics are features that almost every person seeks out, and Hinduism allows me to explore them through my relationship with God. Every day I learn about myself and my identity in new ways is also another day that I learn about my relationship with God. I find myself full of joy and light as I experience the journey, accepting not only my faith but doubt as essential parts along the way so I can keep my steps sure and steady.

Lessons

I was raised in the United Methodist Church. My mother is an active lay member of our local church and serves in the conference. Therefore, I grew up playing in corners during church meetings. Watching my parents, I learned about various expressions of faith-service, friendship, worship. I wasn't raised to think of church as an option-when sports interfered with Sunday morning we found alternate services, when traveling we found a church along our route, or sang a hymn. While my parents were involved and attendance at church never truly up for discussion, I never felt forced into it. I enjoyed church, service and meetings.

I began to really take ownership of my faith in high school, but going to college was the first time I had absolute control over my movements. No one was waking me up on Sunday mornings, no one was going to a meeting and inviting me to tag along. My relationship with God and the church were up to me. I found navigating this freedom fascinating. I reevaluated my beliefs about what  faith looks like. I began this process of determining what traditions I wanted to carry with me, what I felt comfortable moving on from, how God was speaking to me. This process will probably never end-at least I hope it doesn't.

These past three years of constant re-imagining and redefining of my faith life have been exhilarating and life-giving. They have prompted deeper study of my bible, of my church, of myself. They have led me to new opportunities. They have made me uncomfortable. They have taught me that I find God in sunrises and sunsets and walks and empty sanctuaries-things I never indulged before. They have led me to new spiritual practices, like journaling. Most importantly, they have allowed me to see old things in a new light. The past few years I have been captured by sabbath practices-because I am not good at keeping them. I prefer motion to stillness, but I have found more and more that I NEED stillness.  My parents are absurdly busy,  I picked up my addiction to movement from them as much as I did my faith. But in the midst of their running around, they always found ways to pause and allow God to fill them up. Yesterday, a friend told me to find my sabbath and protect it and I immediately thought of driving on some highway with my mother singing Amazing Grace. It was an old lesson that I had to learn again in a new way. I relearn it multiple times a day, week, month, year. I think that is a lot of what I have found about faith in recent years, it is a constant process of discovering and re-discovering, learning and re-learning. I am learning to be open to that cycle, appreciating how God hits me differently at sunrise and at sunset.

The chronicles of growing up choir kid

"How do people who grew up religious move from the taken-for-granted world in which they had been raised to a more deliberate, intentional approach to faith? Many people, of course, do not make this move at all. People from the most intensely religious homes sometimes lose their interest in spirituality, either from sheer boredom or because they found such upbringing oppressive. Others continue on, perhaps claiming to believe what they always did and even attesting to the centrality of faith to their lives, yet doing little as adults to deepen their spirituality. The people I am interested in are the exception to both those patterns. They are the ones who decided at some point that spirituality was a quest worth pursuing actively, a pursuit requiring time and energy."

***

I grew up in an Episcopal church in Connecticut, where I attended service every Sunday from the age of 5 until I was 14. My mom put me in the choir, which rehearsed twice a week and sang every Sunday morning. My brother was in the choir as well, which rehearsed on alternating nights twice a week and sang at the later service on Sunday mornings. This meant that I was at the church Mondays and Wednesdays for my rehearsal, Tuesdays and Thursdays to drop off and pick up my brother, and Sunday mornings at 7:45 am to warm up for the 9 am service, breakfast in the Parish Hall immediately following and then sitting in the pews with my mom for the 11 am service to watch my brother sing. Needless to say, I spent a great deal of time at my church and it became a second home.

Growing up as a choir kid meant I knew all the secret passageways into the heart of the organ, how to sneak up to the top of the bell tower, the best hiding spots in the cemetery during hide-and-seek, where all the leftover food was kept, how to get onto the roof, and which doors the janitor didn't lock that led to spooky, old storage rooms. The church was basically the coolest playground ever. There was a certain amount of discipline instilled in all the choristers trained under the British high-church model. This means that during rehearsal there was absolutely no whispering, no giggling (permission granted if the director made a joke), and no distractions. When it was time for break, we were literally set free to do whatever we wanted without chaperone. There were unspoken expectations like: don't get hurt because we don't want to deal with that, don't get caught because we don't want to deal with that, and come back on time or we will yell at you. Almost a decade of this and I knew the entire church property and all its intricacies like the back of my hand.

On Sunday mornings I arrived at 7:45 without eating breakfast, rehearsed for an hour, put on my red robe and white vestment on top, and lined up for the procession. At my church we snaked around the entire nave until we came down the center aisle and into the choir stalls, which made the whole entrance feel ever more grand. When I was 10, it felt like making my big debut every single time. Sitting in front of the congregation always felt like being on stage to me. We smiled, stood, sat, prayed, sang when we were told. Our only autonomy lay in the little games we would play without the congregation, the ministry team, or our choir director seeing. This included tic-tac-toe, hangman, MASH, doodling, and playing fingers with choristers across the sanctuary. When it was time for communion, my stomach had been rumbling for about an hour at this point, I ate my bread and drank my wine like I had never eaten before. It was the same play every Sunday, same stage directions, same lines, (different songs), same order, same games and I LOVED it.

The choir is responsible for leading the congregation in song and prayer. We were required to say the Apostle's creed, Nicene creed, Lord's Prayer, Benediction, and prayer responses. It was part of my job, (yes, I was paid to be in the choir).

to be continued...

Engagement and Grace

Today, I walked into Marsh Chapel and practiced reading the reflection I wrote for the This I Believe service, where Marsh takes a few members of the graduating class from all around the university and has them reflect on their spiritual journeys. Among us were a wide-variety of different voices, perspectives, and personal narratives.

While these differences contrasted our reflections, there were also resonances between what was said.
We all wrestled throughout our academic journeys
with our place in this universe,
with our sense of God,
and with our sense of vocation.

We all wrestled with the idea of engagement and with the tensions currently facing us around the globe and within our own lives and communities.

In my eyes, this diversity and these resonances reflect the messy beauty that I think underpins this heart in the city that is Marsh Chapel, and it also reflects the wonderful messiness that is Boston University.

I am just a little more than a week away from officially graduating from here, and as I reflect on where I was, where I am, and where I am going in the context of my undergraduate career, two words come to mind: engagement and grace.

The common ground values of Howard Thurman demand engagement with our surrounding world. Holding to these values demand that we, as members of the university community, engage with those around us, with those whom we might call the other, and with those we might not agree. We must engage with the different cultures, contexts, and narratives that exist around our world. In our engagement, we might learn more about this world and – this is especially true – we might learn more about ourselves.

My journey through these last four years has been a journey of grace. I don’t think I’ll ever forget those initial emotions I felt while opening my acceptance letter to this school: at that moment, I felt immediate shock. When I submitted my application, I looked at my own credentials and at the credentials of the incoming class and thought to myself, ‘not a chance, but I’ll submit it anyways.’ The university had such a vibrant spiritual life; they also had a College of Engineering and a School of Theology. I remember thinking, ‘How cool would it be if I was there?’

When I was accepted, the school gave me an opportunity to attend and I immediately enrolled. I visited the school again just to feel what it was like to be there and I kept the hopeful warmth from that visit in my heart as I completed high school.

From that initial moment of grace, I can now trace a long line of people who got me here from all over the university. Throughout my undergraduate career, different people extended their hands to me and helped me along the way. When I was much younger, I never dreamed I could have ended up here. I did not think this future I am now living could have existed. I never thought I could have interned in ministry, or designed circuitry in a lab, or composed prayers to read to others. I never imagined I could have left a splash at all here on campus, and I never believed I could have impacted others in the same ways that people have impacted me.

I never imagined myself going to the School of Theology for graduate studies as it seemed like a distant, impossible, and idealized future. But thanks to the grace of those around me, I am proud to be going there to get my Master of Divinity.

So,
to those I met as an undergraduate student
and wrestled with challenging course material with,
to those I met as a student leader at Orientation
and set the tone of our campus’ culture with,
to those I met as an intern at Marsh Chapel
and engaged in spiritual life at BU with,
to those I met at SojournBU
and wrestled with my spiritual narratives with,
to those I met at EpiscopalBU
and had communion and a meal with,

To those I had the opportunity to share a meal – or a beer – with in conversation,

To those I laughed, danced, explored, inquired, and conversed with,

To those who were there when I needed a hand, an ear, a heart, and a supporting voice,

I say, thank you.

Thank you for the moments you shared with me,

for your impact on my life has been, still is, and always will continue to be
immense,
immeasurable,

And life-giving.

Thankful

I have been thinking about how Marsh Chapel has influenced me, and I think one of the many ways it has changed me is through observing how people interact. There is a sense of purpose and joy in people's eyes. I have become a better listener, more self-aware, more aware of others. I still remember sitting in the lower level of the chapel as a freshman in Brother Larry's FY101 class, writing a letter to my future self, hearing stories about BU, and exploring Boston. The choir at Marsh Chapel still uplifts my spirits every Sunday, but the feeling inside me has changed over time. I want to thank everyone that I have had the opportunity to meet and will always treasure the memories created during my time here.