| Position | Player | Class |
| Catcher | Jeff Fisher | 1990 |
| First Base | Jack (John) Janasiewicz | 1994 |
| Second Base | John Harley | 1994 |
| Shortstop | Dan Donato | 1994 |
| Third Base | Mike Hluska | 1983 |
| Left Field | Dirk Baker | 1991 |
| Center Field | Chris Aufiero | 1994 |
| Right Field | Dave Cunningham | 1990 |
| Pitchers | Gary Pisa | 1988 |
| Paul Perillo | 1990 | |
| Bob Demayo | 1992 | |
| Mike Anselmo | 1996 | |
| Utility | Mike Kelfer | 1989 |
| Tony Lando | 1976 | |
| Glenn Miller | 1982 |