| Position | Name | Class | Honors |
| Catcher: | Bob Maiocco | 1970 | Capt. 1970, NCAA ’68, ’69 |
| First Base: | Pat Petrone | 1965 | GBL All-Star ’65; GBL Champs. ’65 |
| Second Base: | Herb Wakabayashi | 1969 | GBL All-Star ’69, NCAA ’69 |
| Shortstop: | Wally Birchler | 1967 | GBL Batting Champion; GBL Champs ’65 |
| Third Base: | Jimmy Wood | 1967 | GBL All-Star ’67; Capt. ’67; GBL Champs ’65 |
| Left Field: | Reggie Rucker | 1969 | GBL All-Star ’69, NCAA ’68, ’69 |
| Center Field: | Bill Mahoney | 1963 | Co-Capt. 1963 |
| Right Field: | Jack Mahoney | 1965 | GBL All-Star ’63, ’65; Capt. 1965; Champs ’65 |
| Pitchers: | Tim Masick | 1969 | GBL All-Star ’68, ’69; NCAA ’68, ’69 |
| Joe Lasorsa | 1969 | GBL All-Star ’69; NCAA ’69 | |
| Nick Stipanovich | 1969 | NCAA ’68 | |
| Jack Mara | 1968 | Co-Capt. 1968; NCAA ’68 | |
| Jim McLaughlin | 1968 | NCAA ’68 | |
| Utility Players: | Bruce Taylor | 1970 | GBL All-Star ’68; NCAA ’68, ’69 |
| Peter Yetten | 1971 | Capt. 1971 | |
| Paul Fontas | 1969, ’74 | GBL All-Star ’67; NCAA ’68 ’69 |