| Position | Player | Class |
| Catcher | Tom Gastall | 1955 |
| First Base | Harry Agganis | 1954 |
| Second Base | Johnny Nunziato | 1954 |
| Shortstop | Johnny Murphy | 1958 |
| Third Base | Don Russell | 1954 |
| Left Field | Lenny Dempsey | 1957 |
| Center Field | Bill Mahoney | 1963 |
| Right Field | Mike Bobrowiecki | 1954 |
| Alt. First Base | Larry McNulty | 1962 |
| Pitchers | Don MacLeod | 1958 |
| Vaughn Stedman | 1954 | |
| Billy Tighe | 1949 |
Source: Boston Traveler May 21, 1962 article BU’S Retiring Cleverly Picks All-Time Teams